What Should You Know Before Getting a Working Dog?

What Are the Implications of Buying a Dog with a Specific Working Purpose (e.g., Herding, Guarding)?

Buying a dog for a specific working purpose—such as herding livestock or guarding your home—is no small decision. These dogs are bred to work and come with energy, instincts, and training needs that are miles beyond your average family pet. Owning a working dog can be an incredibly rewarding experience, but it also comes with challenges, responsibilities, and special requirements. The implications of owning a working breed go far beyond regular walks and playtime. Let's explore what that really means for you as a potential dog owner.

Understanding the Implications of Buying a Working Dog: Herding, Guarding, and Beyond

When you buy a dog bred for a specific working purpose, you're not just getting a pet—you're getting a partner with deep-rooted instincts. From herding dogs like Border Collies to guarding dogs like German Shepherds, these breeds have specific physical and mental needs. Owning a working dog means committing to regular training, ample exercise, and mental stimulation. Failure to meet these needs can result in frustration and undesirable behaviors. Understanding the dog's background, training needs, and health concerns is crucial to ensuring a happy and healthy partnership.

Introduction: Working Dogs Are More Than Pets—They're Partners

If you've ever watched a Border Collie herd sheep or seen a Doberman patrol a yard, you'll understand that these dogs have a higher calling than just wagging tails and fetching balls. They are bred for specific tasks, and their personalities, behavior, and energy levels reflect that purpose.

But is owning a working dog right for you? This guide will walk you through everything you need to know about these dynamic animals—from their exercise needs to training, health concerns, and even the pros and cons of owning one in a family environment. Whether you're thinking of getting a herding, guarding, or service dog, the journey to becoming a working dog owner is packed with both rewards and responsibilities.

1. What Exactly Is a Working Dog? (And Why It Matters)

Working dogs are a unique category in the canine world. They aren't just bred for companionship but for specific tasks like herding, guarding, hunting, or performing service duties. When you think of working dogs, breeds like the Australian Shepherd, Rottweiler, or Labrador Retriever probably come to mind. These dogs have been shaped through generations of selective breeding to excel at particular jobs, which means they come with both physical and mental characteristics designed to get the job done.

For instance, a Border Collie is notorious for its herding drive—this dog will round up anything, from sheep to children, thanks to its ingrained instincts. On the flip side, a Doberman Pinscher has strong guarding instincts, making it an excellent watchdog. However, if those instincts aren't properly managed, it can lead to behavioral issues.

Are you ready to own a dog that might view your family cat as something to "herd" or that takes guarding so seriously it may struggle with strangers?

2. Historical Origins: The Purpose Behind the Breed

To really appreciate a working dog's behavior, it's essential to understand their history. Working dogs didn't pop up overnight; they've been shaped by thousands of years of selective breeding. For example, the Rottweiler was originally a Roman drover dog, used to herd cattle across long distances, while the Border Collie has herding roots in the hilly Scottish Borders.

These historical roles influence modern behavior in a big way. A Border Collie, for instance, might feel restless in an apartment without regular opportunities to exercise its body and mind. Understanding a dog's historical purpose can help you manage their instincts and behaviors more effectively.

3. Modern-Day Working Dogs: How Their Roles Have Shifted

In today's world, fewer dogs are used for their original working purposes, but that doesn't mean their instincts have disappeared. While German Shepherds might not be patrolling estates, they've become popular in police and military work due to their intelligence and trainability. Similarly, Border Collies can thrive in competitive dog sports like agility, even if they aren't working sheep.

However, this shift presents a new challenge: these dogs still need a job. Whether it's running through an agility course, mastering obedience training, or engaging in search-and-rescue work, working dogs crave mental and physical stimulation. If you're not prepared to provide this, a working dog might not be the right fit for your lifestyle.

4. Energy Levels: Ready to Handle a Marathon Runner?

Owning a working dog means signing up for some serious exercise—both for the dog and you. These breeds are wired for long days of physical activity. A Husky, bred for sled pulling, or an Australian Cattle Dog, bred to herd livestock, isn't going to be content with just a 20-minute walk around the block.

Expect to invest time in daily exercise that pushes your dog both physically and mentally. Without these outlets, many working dogs turn to destructive behaviors like chewing furniture, barking excessively, or digging. Keeping a working dog stimulated is your biggest responsibility as an owner—and no, throwing a tennis ball twice won't cut it!

5. Training: You're Not Just Teaching Tricks—You're Shaping Behavior

Training is arguably the most critical aspect of owning a working dog. These dogs aren't only highly intelligent, but they also have strong instincts that need to be channeled. For example, herding dogs like Border Collies have a natural desire to round up anything in their path. If you don't guide that instinct early on, you might find your dog trying to "herd" children, cars, or even the family cat.

For guarding breeds like the Rottweiler or Doberman, proper socialization is key. These dogs need to know how to differentiate between actual threats and everyday interactions, so they don't become overprotective or anxious around new people.

Training a working dog isn't a one-and-done deal. It's a lifelong commitment to engaging their mind and reinforcing good behavior. And yes, it requires patience—so much patience!

6. Real-Life Examples: Herding and Guarding in Action

Let's compare two typical working dog scenarios. Picture a Border Collie working on a sheep farm. The dog spends its days running up and down fields, tirelessly rounding up livestock. Its mind is focused, its body is engaged, and its instincts are fulfilled.

Now imagine a German Shepherd living in the city. It's probably not guarding sheep, but it could be trained in protection work, agility, or obedience competitions. These dogs excel in tasks that allow them to use their natural abilities, whether in a rural or urban setting.

The lesson here? The environment doesn't matter as much as whether or not you're giving your dog a job to do.

7. Health Issues: Working Breeds Have Their Quirks

Like all breeds, working dogs have their own set of health concerns. For instance, German Shepherds and Rottweilers are prone to hip and elbow dysplasia, a condition where the joints develop improperly, causing pain and mobility issues. Border Collies can suffer from Collie Eye Anomaly, a genetic condition affecting the retina.

Because working dogs are so active, they're also more prone to injuries like ligament tears. It's crucial to invest in routine veterinary care and monitor their health closely. Preventive care and a balanced diet can make a huge difference in the long-term well-being of your working dog.

8. Interesting Facts: Did You Know?

Here's a fun fact to impress your dog-loving friends: Border Collies are the Einsteins of the dog world, known to understand over 1,000 words! Or how about this? The Rottweiler is one of the oldest herding breeds, dating back to Roman times.

Working dogs are full of fascinating quirks, and understanding these traits makes owning one even more rewarding.

9. Challenges: Why Owning a Working Dog Isn't Always Easy

Working dogs are intelligent and driven, but that also means they can get bored or frustrated if their needs aren't met. When this happens, you'll likely see undesirable behaviors—chewing, barking, digging, or even aggression. Herding dogs might nip at heels, while guarding breeds can become territorial or anxious around strangers.

One big challenge? Compatibility with small children or other pets. Herding dogs have been known to try herding children, which can lead to nipping or chasing behaviors. Proper socialization is a must to avoid these issues.

10. Success Tips: How to Make Your Life with a Working Dog Easier

So, how do you make your working dog happy? The answer lies in routine, structure, and engagement. These dogs thrive when they have a purpose, whether it's learning new tricks, running through an agility course, or participating in dog sports.

Early training and socialization are essential, as well as finding ways to challenge your dog mentally and physically. And don't forget to give them plenty of love and attention—they're working dogs, but they still need affection!

Conclusion: Is a Working Dog Right for You?

Working dogs are amazing companions, but they aren't for everyone. They require time, energy, and commitment to thrive. If you're prepared to meet their unique needs, they'll reward you with loyalty, intelligence, and companionship. However, if you're looking for a low-maintenance pet, you might want to consider another breed.

Before bringing home a working dog, ask yourself: Are you ready for the exercise, training, and long-term commitment. 

Did You Enjoy this Article? Share it and Help Us Spread the Word!

If you found this article helpful, we'd appreciate it if you could share it with your friends or link to it from your website, blog, or group! You can also use the convenient social share tabs on the left side of the screen to instantly share this page to your social media feed. For more ways to support and promote the American Breeder Community, visit our  Share & Promote Together  page for social media posts and memes you can copy and share. Your support means the world to us!

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, medical, financial, or professional advice. While we strive for accuracy, we make no representations or warranties regarding the completeness, accuracy, reliability, or suitability of the information. Please consult with a professional before making decisions based on the content provided. American Breeder Inc. assumes no responsibility for any errors or omissions or for the results obtained from the use of this information. 

HOW TO USE AMERICAN BREEDER