Assessing the Risks of Buying a Dog Bred for Specific Traits: A Comprehensive Guide

When purchasing a dog bred for specific traits such as size or color, it's essential to consider the health, temperament, and genetic risks that may accompany these physical attributes. Selective breeding often focuses on appearance but can lead to underlying issues like hereditary diseases, behavior problems, or reduced lifespans. To make an informed decision, research the breed, ensure the breeder follows ethical practices, and prioritize the dog's health and well-being over aesthetic traits.

The Risks Behind the Cuteness: What You Need to Know Before Buying a Dog Bred for Traits

Let's be honest: who hasn't fallen for an adorable dog with a perfectly curled tail, those dreamy blue eyes, or an impossibly tiny size? It's natural to be attracted to a dog for its looks, but there's a lot more under the surface that could impact your pup's future health and behavior. Buying a dog based on appearance alone can be risky business. Whether it's a teacup breed, a merle coat, or an extra-large canine, the decisions made in selective breeding often come with hidden consequences. So how can you assess these risks and ensure you're making the best choice for both you and your future furry friend? Let's dig in.

Breeding for Size: The Challenges of Going Big or Small

Teacup Breeds: Tiny Dog, Big Problems

Sure, teacup dogs look like they belong in a purse, but they often come with a laundry list of health issues. When breeders aim for extreme smallness, like in teacup Chihuahuas or Pomeranians, they're essentially creating dogs that are more fragile than your smartphone.

• Fragile Bones: Teacup dogs are prone to bone fractures from the most minor bumps or falls.
• Heart Problems: Many of these dogs have tiny hearts that are prone to serious health complications, leading to early onset of heart disease.
• Shorter Lifespans and High Vet Bills: While these pint-sized pups may seem perfect, their health issues often mean frequent (and expensive) vet visits and a shorter lifespan than their larger counterparts.
  
  

If you're considering a teacup breed, ask yourself: are you prepared for the potential heartbreak and medical costs that come with owning a dog whose small size puts it at such a disadvantage?

The Giants: When Bigger Isn't Always Better

On the opposite end of the size spectrum, we have the gentle giants—Great Danes, Saint Bernards, and Mastiffs. They're impressive, but being big doesn't come without a cost.

• Joint Issues and Hip Dysplasia: Larger breeds often suffer from conditions like hip dysplasia, where the hip socket doesn't properly support the joint. This can lead to arthritis and mobility problems early in life.
• Short Lifespans: Giant breeds rarely make it past the age of 8, so your time together may be heartbreakingly short.
• Expensive Care: These dogs eat a lot and require larger doses of medications, making their care more expensive over time.
  
  

Is having a larger-than-life companion worth the short lifespan and potential medical struggles? It's something to consider when choosing a breed.

Color and Coat: When Beauty Comes with a Price Tag on Health

The Merle Coat Mystery: Is It Worth the Risk?

Merle coats are undeniably stunning, but breeding for this color pattern can come with major health risks. Merle dogs, especially double-merles, are more likely to be born blind or deaf. This genetic combination doesn't just affect coat color—it can impact the dog's overall health and well-being.

• Deafness: A high percentage of merle-colored dogs, particularly Dalmatians and Australian Shepherds, are born with congenital deafness.
• Eye Problems: Dogs with merle coats are also prone to vision issues, including blindness or underdeveloped eyes.
  
  

If you're falling for a merle-colored dog, make sure the breeder is responsible and uses genetic testing to reduce the risks of these health problems.

The Albino Effect: White Coats, Sensitive Skin

Dogs with predominantly white coats, like the Bull Terrier or Dalmatian, often face skin sensitivities and a higher risk of sunburn, due to a lack of pigment in their skin.

• Skin Cancer: Just like humans, dogs with less pigmentation are more susceptible to skin cancer, especially if they spend time in the sun.
• Eye Sensitivity: White-coated dogs may also experience increased sensitivity to bright light due to albinism or partial albinism.
  
  

Genetic Bottlenecking: The Invisible Threat of Limited Gene Pools

Genetic bottlenecking happens when dogs are bred from a small gene pool to preserve specific traits. In other words, when breeders focus on a certain color, size, or appearance, they may unintentionally limit genetic diversity. This can lead to hereditary diseases becoming more prevalent within a breed.

• Weakened Immune Systems: Dogs with limited genetic diversity are more likely to inherit immune system deficiencies, which make them more susceptible to illness.
• Hereditary Diseases: Breeding for traits like color or size can increase the risk of conditions like epilepsy, hip dysplasia, and heart defects being passed down through generations.
  
  

Always ask your breeder about the genetic diversity of their breeding stock and whether they conduct health screenings to avoid these issues.

Behavioral Considerations: Looks Aren't Everything

Tiny Dogs, Big Attitudes: The Behavioral Effects of Breeding for Size

You've probably heard the phrase "small dog syndrome," and it's not just a myth. Dogs bred to be ultra-small can develop behavior problems due to their fragility and the way humans tend to treat them. These dogs may be more anxious or aggressive because they're constantly in fear of being hurt.

• Anxiety: Constantly being handled and the stress of their size can lead tiny dogs to develop anxiety, which manifests in barking, aggression, or fear.
• Aggression: Because they're treated like fragile little accessories, teacup dogs may become defensive and bite more than larger breeds.
  
  

If you're drawn to a small dog for its size, make sure you're prepared to properly train and socialize them to avoid these common behavioral pitfalls.

Is It Ethical to Breed for Traits? The Debate Over Looks vs. Health

This is a tough question with no easy answer. Breeding for specific traits like color, size, or coat pattern can sometimes lead to dogs suffering unnecessarily from health issues that could have been avoided. As a potential dog owner, it's important to weigh the pros and cons of these decisions.

• Ethical Breeding: Responsible breeders will prioritize health and temperament over appearance. They'll conduct health screenings and ensure their breeding practices reduce the risk of hereditary diseases.
• The Cost of Aesthetics: When breeders focus on producing rare or desirable traits, it can come at the cost of the dog's long-term health and well-being.
  
  

Would you still want that blue-eyed puppy if you knew it might go blind in a few years?

How to Choose a Responsible Breeder: Your Guide to Avoiding Red Flags

If you're set on a specific breed or look, the best way to avoid future problems is to choose a responsible breeder who prioritizes health over appearance. Here's what to look for:

• Health Testing: Ask for documentation of health tests on both parent dogs. This should include screening for common hereditary diseases, hip dysplasia, and eye problems.
• Breeding Practices: A good breeder will only have one or two litters at a time and will be able to explain their breeding practices, including how they select for health and temperament, not just looks.
• Transparency: Ethical breeders are open about the risks of breeding for certain traits and will provide lifetime support for the dogs they breed.
  
  

Remember, a flashy website or Instagram feed doesn't mean a breeder is responsible. Do your homework!

Common Challenges of Owning a Dog Bred for Specific Traits

If you've decided to go ahead with buying a dog bred for specific traits, it's essential to know the common challenges you might face:

• Veterinary Costs: Dogs bred for extreme traits often require more medical care throughout their lives.
• Shorter Lifespan: Many dogs bred for size, especially giant breeds, have shorter lifespans than average.
• Behavioral Training: Dogs bred for size or appearance may require specialized training to address anxiety or aggression that can result from selective breeding.
  
  

Conclusion: Balancing Beauty and Health in Dog Breeding

So, should you buy that teacup Yorkie or that blue-eyed Aussie? The answer depends on how much you're willing to prioritize health and longevity over looks. By choosing a responsible breeder, ensuring proper health testing, and being aware of the risks, you can find a dog that doesn't just look good but lives a long, healthy, and happy life. After all, your dog's companionship will matter far more in the long run than any trait you can see on the surface.

Did You Enjoy this Article? Share it and Help Us Spread the Word!

If you found this article helpful, we'd appreciate it if you could share it with your friends or link to it from your website, blog, or group! You can also use the convenient social share tabs on the left side of the screen to instantly share this page to your social media feed. For more ways to support and promote the American Breeder Community, visit our  Share & Promote Together  page for social media posts and memes you can copy and share. Your support means the world to us!

Add This Article to Your Favorites

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, medical, financial, or professional advice. While we strive for accuracy, we make no representations or warranties regarding the completeness, accuracy, reliability, or suitability of the information. Please consult with a professional before making decisions based on the content provided. American Breeder Inc. assumes no responsibility for any errors or omissions or for the results obtained from the use of this information. 

HOW TO USE AMERICAN BREEDER